Review Process

The JAFR manuscript review process typically involves several stages, including initial evaluation by the editor, then external peer review by experts, and finally a decision by the editor based on the reviewer reports. The duration of the review process varies depending on the journal and the complexity of the manuscript. 

Here's a more detailed breakdown:

  1. Initial Assessment by Editor:

Upon submission, the editor assesses the manuscript to ensure it aligns with the journal's scope and meets basic quality standards. 

  1. Peer Review:

If the initial assessment is positive, the manuscript is sent for peer review by two reviewers relevant to the field. 

  1. Reviewer Reports:

Reviewers evaluate the manuscript's originality, significance, and validity. 

  1. Editor's Decision:

The editor carefully considers the reviewer reports and makes a decision, which could be acceptance, rejection, or a request for revisions. 

  1. Revision and Resubmission:

If revisions are requested, the author revises the manuscript according to the reviewer's comments and resubmits it. 

  1. Final Decision:

After the revision, the editor and reviewers may further assess the revised manuscript, and a final decision is made. 

  1. Publication:

If accepted, the manuscript is prepared for publication and undergoes proofreading and final editing.